Chalkhills Digest, Volume 3, Number 109 Wednesday, 7 May 1997 Today's Topics: re: XTC - who really wants them ? Re: Close But No Cigar Pt. 384 reach out and touch someone OTHER PLANS MADE FOR NIGEL XTC -- I really want them! Ben&Jerry&Andy&Colin&Dave... The Ladybird was Colin Great XTC moment recent 'hills That darn demo Sorry, Stormy Monday... Girl talk Who exactly is Charlie Parker? Time for another Chalkhillian survey! Melissa is an anagram for aimless Ye Olde XTC Ice Cream Parlor XTC Ice Cream Flavor harmonies I Scream Man Tape Orders Received Re: Dave Marsh XTC - I love 'em ! Is it mutual ?? re: Rolling Stone blurbs... Oranges and Lemons mini-disk for trade Political Party Animal Administrivia: Chalkhills is digested with Digest 3.3d (John Relph <relph@sgi.com>). To UNSUBSCRIBE from the Chalkhills mailing list, send a message to <chalkhills-request@chalkhills.org> with the following command: unsubscribe chalkhills For all other administrative issues, send a message to: <chalkhills-request@chalkhills.org> Please remember to send your Chalkhills postings to: <chalkhills@chalkhills.org> World Wide Web: <http://chalkhills.org/> The views expressed herein are those of the individual authors. Misery oh oh misery.
---------------------------------------------------------------------- From: "Volker Dieling" <dieling@hrz1.uni-oldenburg.de> Organization: University Of Oldenburg Comp.Center Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 14:18:56 MEZ-1MESZ Subject: re: XTC - who really wants them ? Message-ID: <31DA16D3183@hrz1.uni-oldenburg.de> He's right, you know. I love XTC, but, if I was responsible for signing or not signing them, I probably wouldn't, since I'd love my job even more. Sad but true. XTC song of the day: The Forgotten Language of Light Lemoncurry dieling@hrz1.pcnet.uni-oldeburg.de Lemons shall rule the world !
------------------------------ From: stewart@bigmon.boulder.co.us (Stewart Evans) Subject: Re: Close But No Cigar Pt. 384 Date: Sun, 4 May 1997 23:52:32 -0600 (MDT) Message-ID: <9705042354.aa29315@bigmon.boulder.co.us> ->From: Scott Tury <stury@ids2.idsonline.com> ->Yes, XTC is protected under Copyright law, but it's still "fair-use" ->outside of the music industry. As long as two companies own the ->same/similar name in different areas of bussiness it's perfectly legal. Not quite true. A band (or company) name, like XTC, is not covered under copyright, at least under US law. It _could_ be registered as a trademark. Trademark law is where the difference in areas of business comes in -- it's generally not considered infringement of trademark unless your business is judged likely to be confused with that of the existing trademark holder. However, unless you apply for a trademark (and go through the associated governmental search for conflicting trademarks), you don't get any trademark protection. Under copyright law, you may be entitled to protection of an unregistered work, provided you can prove that you've taken steps to identify the work as your own (for instance, allowing someone to print your song in a songbook without credit would not be a good idea). Again this is based on my understanding of US law, and I'm not a lawyer... -- Stewart
------------------------------ From: "KIMBERLY MARTIN" <KMAR0971@Mercury.GC.PeachNet.EDU> Organization: Gainesville College in Oakwood, GA Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 14:01:41 EST5EDT Subject: reach out and touch someone Message-ID: <663C917AE6@Mercury.GC.PeachNet.EDU> Hello chalkies... Greetings from Gainesville once again! Just a random commentary, once again, on things I've read in the recent posts...as far as posts not pertaining to XTC...yes, I know that I'm already guilty of committing this heinous sin. However, if I talk about a non-XTC band (such as the Swamp Zombies), it's not to bore the pants off of anyone reading, but rather just to find some people that have other common interests as me. I could do a list of my favourite XTC albums in order, but everytime I listen to one of their albums I catch something different and by the time it's posted my opinion might have changed! But I might just do it anyway...my favorite XTC album has always been and always will be "English Settlement," with "Skylarking" coming in a close second, "Mummer" being third....ahh, see, it's hard to do rankings, they're all wonderful. It's great fun to play "Go2" or "White Music" for people who have only heard songs like "Dear God," they don't know what to make of all the spazziness! okay, and about the ethnic/wife beating joke...my main problem with the joke was that it just wasn't funny. i really wasn't offended, I guess this may have a lot to do with the fact that I come from a region where bigotry is rampant (does anyone know who Danny "KKK guy" Carver is?? He's been on Howard Stern's tv show a few times...well, that guy lives in my town), not to mention the fact that I'm right in the buckle of the bible belt. So I've been hearing many, MANY worse things than that joke for almost 19 years now, and not that I condone it, I'm just immune to it. But yeah, beating someone's wife to death isn't funny, and I'm sure there are plenty of websites out there that cater to this type of humor if that's your thing; an xtc discussion list is probably NOT the best place to be un-p.c. Amanda, you said something about airing your views on vegetarianism?? I could maybe put mine out in the open, but I probably wouldn't make any friends that way (read: I EAT MEAT AND I DON'T LISTEN TO PREACHING FROM SOMEONE WHO WON'T EAT CHEESE BUT IS WEARING A PAIR OF LEATHER SANDALS). ah, there I go again contradicting myself. anyway, on the subject of Dave Marsh/rock critics...I'm not really familiar with Mr. Marsh's work, but I'm not a huge fan of rock critics in general. I used to subscribe to SPIN and Alternative Press, magazines whose sole purpose in existance is so the writers can justify their miserable existances with hipper-than-though tirades against any band that doesn't fit into their narrow category of "cool", by constantly name-dropping and alluding to obscure "underground" bands that no one's ever heard of, yet are supposedly the founding fathers of music as we know it, and giving glowing reviews to any crap that U2, Pearl Jam, or Perry Farrell decide to churn out. I think that a music reviewer should tell me what the music sounds like, yet most reviews don't impart this info-- they're just a huge mess of $3 words and extended metaphorical allusions ("twisting, twirling, and churning on the edge of intellectual chasms, this 4- piece post-punk-art-grunge-group from Jersey sonically assault the lobes with a whirling dervish of antidisestablishmentarianism..." well, you get the idea...)and after I read it I still don't know if I should go out and buy the CD or not. Usually, when a reviewer makes fun of a band or talks about how irritating they are, I end up loving the band. When a reviewer tries to give a TRULY irritating and sucky band (read: WEEN) more credit than they deserve, I am just ever more justified in my opinion that record reviewers are for the most part full of it. I really don't understand what makes someone's musical opinion more important than someone else's anyway; it's all about personal taste, and what makes these guys' personal tastes so much better than anyone elses? Just cos they know more about the history of music? Or because they know a lot of big words?? ah, opinions, opinions, they're just like....well, you know, everyone has one!! i'm really open-minded though, I love to hear other people's opinions. My opinions at times aren't even based in reality, just the way I feel... But yeah, XTC!! Sometimes I do find it hard to say anything new or relevant about them, cos as we all know, not much is going on in their world...I have a question, I hope it's okay to mention this subject on this list, but does anyone know if Andy & co. were dosing up any LSD around the time of the Dukes of Stratosphear (or at any time for that matter)? I say yeah, one of my friends says no, they're just PRETENDING to do drugs. well, I'd better not say any more on that subject, just in case. well, enough opinions, back to more relevant things! please write! Kim
------------------------------ Date: Mon, 05 May 97 14:26:37 PST From: "MARK HEGGEN" <mark_heggen@studio.disney.com> Message-Id: <9704058628.AA862867964@ccmsmtp2.wds.disney.com> Subject: OTHER PLANS MADE FOR NIGEL All: OK, here is a counterexample of someone doing a GREAT version of "Nigel": On Valentine's Day at Largo in LA, saw Jon Brion (ex-Grays, Jellyfish, etc.) render the song by request--on a pump organ, bedecked with lit candles! The audience, obviously well-versed in XTC, filled in very well on all the backing vocals. And Mr. Brion can add Nigel to his core list of impeccable covers (the best being various versions of "Waterloo Sunset"; though he also did wow us that same night with an impromptu slab of Abbey Road Side 2). -Mark
------------------------------ From: Martin_Monkman@fincc04.fin.gov.bc.ca Date: Mon, 05 May 1997 15:11:19 -0700 (PDT) Subject: XTC -- I really want them! Message-id: <9704058628.AA862870213@FINSMTP1.FIN.GOV.BC.CA> Peter Wright asks "XTC - Who really wants them?" and >WHERE IS THE NEW ALBUM, BOYS ?!!! Initially I draughted a 10 page, point-by-point dissection of Peter's post. But for brevity's sake all I'll say is ... I too am lamenting the delay, but much of the cause lies beyond the band's sphere of influence; i.e. they aren't entirely to blame. And as to the claim that they can't get a deal, many records are independently produced and earn modest amounts of income for their creators and the companies that make, distribute, and sell them. XTC's search is for a label that will help them achieve their commercially modest ambitions while allowing them to pursue their own artistic direction. While it seems unlikely that The Major Labels won't want to handle them, an independent label that can get copies into the stores and mentioned in the press will succeed in turning a profit from the next XTC album. Patience, Martin
------------------------------ Message-Id: <v03102801af941292a3db@[207.77.26.123]> Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 18:46:24 -0400 From: Ira Lieman <ira@myself.com> Subject: Ben&Jerry&Andy&Colin&Dave... Mitch wrote: >So let's say someone like Ben and Jerry's was going to name an ice cream >flavor >after XTC. What would they call it? You're cool. :) My fave of yours is "It's Nearly Apricot" but I'd personally go for "Making Plans For Nougat" or "Prince of Orange Sherbet" If I were a bartender, how about a drink called "Train Running Low on SoCo?" If I was naming for John Lennon it might be "Instant Caramel" Keep up the good work. -ira
------------------------------ Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 17:58:40 -0700 (PDT) Message-Id: <v01510101af93cebaf2c6@[206.15.68.81]> From: mf@well.com (Mitch Friedman) Subject: The Ladybird was Colin The very first time I ever spoke to Andy (on the phone in January '84) I asked him the very same question about "Ladybird" that Cheryl posed last time. He told me that while they were recording, Colin played a bad note and yelled out and it went down one of the drum mikes and they couldn't get rid of it so they just decided to leave it in there. If you can find the Musician magazine issue from around that same time, there is a very long and nice article/interview with XTC all about Mummer (I think they referred to XTC as "Electric Farmboys") in which Andy actually mentions that he was just talking to somebody on the phone the other day and they asked about that yelling in "Ladybird".
------------------------------ Message-Id: <v01540b00af9445e29a89@[132.170.24.118]> Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 21:32:23 -0500 From: dcm80229@pegasus.cc.ucf.edu (Derek Miner) Subject: Great XTC moment I wanted to share an incredible XTC moment with everyone... I had what I would consider to be the third best XTC moment I could have. First being actually meeting the band, and second getting a new CD. Here's the story... I walked into work the other day at the record store to discover some autographed album flats (those 12"x12" cards of album artwork used for promotion) on the counter. One of them was of Oranges and Lemons! After the whole day had gone by and nothing had been done with the flats, I asked the manager what was going to be done with them, and if I may be able to have the XTC one... He said they were going to be put up on the wall with the other autographs. I politely pointed out that there already was an XTC flat on the wall. He then HANDED ME THE AUTOGRAPHED FLAT! I am now the owner of an autographed Oranges and Lemons album artwork flat! Andy and Colin signed in silver marker, and Dave signed in black. I think this will tide me over until the boys record a new disc. = Derek Miner = http://pegasus.cc.ucf.edu/~dcm80229/
------------------------------ From: artsy@sprynet.com Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 20:13:35 -0700 Message-Id: <199705060313.UAA04857@m7.sprynet.com> Subject: recent 'hills Hey folx- Just caught up on the last 3 'hills, and wanted to make a few comments - God, the note about 5 years was depressing, although I figured it was close to that. Rob Cumberland: I bow down to your humor, especially "The List of Everything". WHEN will this be available, and do you accept VISA? Will a CD-ROM version be available? - because I'm afraid the printed version will be too large & heavy to be very portable. Maybe versions could be put out by category: "The List of All Restaurants in the Known Universe", etc. Peter Wright: I agree with the vast majority of your comments on our boys, their label situation, Andy, etc. I only hope that despite all that, they'll still be able to get signed & put out a label THIS YEAR. Jason Phelan: People thought you were SERIOUS?!! Hah! We're just desperate for new material, eh? OK, I didn't mean to make fun of those of you who fell for it... Jason Garcia: McCartney's album did NOT come out on April 29 as you'd told us, but will come out on May 27, I believe. AND, since you're dissin' Bruce Horsnby, I'd suggest you check out "Harbor Lights" before you make your final statement on the man. :^) Seriously - it's great. Simon: Man, hang in there! You're still cool! Quit falling all over yourself apologizing about apologizing (to the 3rd power?). BTW, if anyone's starting to think that lots of us can't be trusted (and I'm NOT belittling Michael Myers' post!!!), I just want to go on record saying that I offered to get & mail copies of "Costello & Nieve" to the first takers, and I came through. And I think the 3 amigos that responded to my offer will pay me as well (one has already, thanks!).
------------------------------ Message-ID: <336EAEAC.1214@bc.sympatico.ca> Date: Mon, 05 May 1997 23:10:09 -0500 From: Steve Clarke <stephen_clarke@bc.sympatico.ca> Subject: That darn demo Chalk-types: I think I'm out of the loop (or living in a virtual cave) but can someone PLEASE tell me where I can get the demos. I currently carpool with asomeone who only listnes to Van Morrison and CBC news and need something else NEW!!! I'm all in favour of someone posting clips in realaudio format or similar. After five XTC-free years....I'll settle for anything new. On another note, the inedendent FM statio in Bellingham WA (92.9 FM-if you're in southern BC or NW Washington, check it out)has been using the intro from "Nigel" under public service announcements for some time now. This on an XTC free station. Why save the best tunes for the bits no-one listens to? Steve Clarke (Canadian edition)
------------------------------ Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 08:44:48 +0200 (METDST) From: James Isaacs <jisaacs1@aixterm1.urz.uni-heidelberg.de> Subject: Sorry, Stormy Monday... Message-Id: <Pine.A32.3.91.970506084220.39023A-100000@aixub1.urz.uni-heidelberg.de> I am listening to the new Paul CD, Flaming Pie, as I scribble this. It is pretty darned good. Only 2 of the 14 songs has what we consider "that darned Jeff Lynne"-type production. The songs aren't about beating seals either. Not out in the states until May 27. Is there a plan to release "Upsy Daisy" in Europe, or is it Geffen-only? James
------------------------------ Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 02:08:20 -0700 Message-Id: <v01510101af94a2ae4042@[194.128.83.69]> From: fisher@easynet.co.uk (Mark Fisher) Subject: Girl talk I've already lost most of my credibility by admitting to buying a Robbie Williams single, so I will blow it completely by confessing that I've been finding the Cathy Dennis album, Am I the Kinda Girl, rather enjoyable. I don't even think the Andy Partridge title track is the best thing on it. Is there any hope for me? Am I alone?
------------------------------ Date: Tue, 06 May 1997 08:26:31 -0500 (CDT) From: amanda caryl owens <ACOEA@jazz.ucc.uno.edu> Subject: Who exactly is Charlie Parker? Message-id: <01IIJJPJFHRM8Y0W3E@jazz.ucc.uno.edu> I ask this because I know Andy's dog is (was?) named Charlie Parker, and b/c on my soap (yes, I watch the bastard son of fantasy, the soap opera), a guy just named this parrot that flew into this window Charlie Parker. So who IS this Charlie Parker????? Yes Josh, I'm growing up. Time to break out the frilly white dresses and expensive mansions, I'm having my debut! (Hardly!) Becki, I am sitting in insane jealousy of anyone who has heard your cd. My parents supply all my funds, seeing as that my sorry ass has no job, and they won't let me get a copy! FINALLY got to see some more videotape of XTC stuff. David Letterman really has no idea, does he......and I could've sworn I saw Yahoo Serious introduce them one time........ Ciao, Amanda XTc song of the day-Dame Fortune non XTC song of the day-Black Water-Doobie Brothers
------------------------------ Date: Tue, 06 May 1997 09:07:19 -0500 (CDT) From: amanda caryl owens <ACOEA@jazz.ucc.uno.edu> Subject: Time for another Chalkhillian survey! Message-id: <01IIJL2NOKRM8Y0W3E@jazz.ucc.uno.edu> And I thought I'd get this done before I have to leave school for the summer, so here goes nothing.... This is a general survey to see who is listening to XTC these days. I got the idea for this survey when my friend Kevin asked what I think the "typical" XTC fan is like. So I am here to find out just how typical, or atypical, we are. And here we go! 1.-Age 2.-Sex 3.-Religion (youcould put whatever you want here, you know Church of Christ the Double Glazing Salesman, or Gary's Witnesses, pick your preference.) 4.-Current country of residence. 5.-Sexual orientation (I'm not gonna post names, and I won't keep anyone in my memory, so just be straight with me....no pun intended.) 6.-Marital status 7.-How old were you when you started listening to XTC? 8.-What was the first song you heard by XTC? 9.-Do you have any close friends who listen to XTC/do you know anyone who listens to XTC? 10.-Race That's all for now. Send your answers directly to me, not to the list, and I will compile them and post them as soon as I'm done. I'll give you about a week from the time the digest that has this post in it to send me your answers, so please do it! This is my last survey before summer! Ciao (again), Amanda
------------------------------ From: Melsta@aol.com Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 11:42:48 -0400 (EDT) Message-ID: <970506114247_841110884@emout10.mail.aol.com> Subject: Melissa is an anagram for aimless Hello Chock-a-Blockers! (or should that be Chalk-a-Blalkers? I think not) Only the brave Todd Bernhardt answered my call for Life's like a verses. And quite admirably too: >> Life's like a kind word >> It makes your face blush >> 'Til you realize this life ain't modest and then: >> Life's like a pumpkin >> You're only carved once >> And you wait for love to light the candle >> Of course, you could come up with a variety of endings on that one -- >> rotting in the back yard (like Peter), getting smashed in the street by some >> young hooligans, you name it... No others came forward. I've been cursed with writer's block on the subject myself, though. I had several good ones about 6 months ago Oh well. We also had two (or one-and-a-half) entries in the rewrite an XTC song challenge. Both worthy efforts. I especially thought Chris Coolidge's Dear Andy was for-mee-DAH-bla (translation: pretty cool). Regarding the Polish wife-beating joke, I am genuinely shocked that people could be offended by something like that. It's not about dumb Central Europeans, nor is it about domestic violence. It's a clever retelling of the Abraham-Isaac sacrifice tale from the Bible. Except in this case, the ersatz Abraham didn't get the message from the all-powerful (the Mob boss) not to go through with it (blanks in the gun), and so sacrificed his beloved anyway. What if, when god stayed Abraham's hand, Abe thought it was temporary paralysis brought on by stress and imperfect obedience, and proceeded to stomp the boy to death? That's what this "joke" is really asking. It's more of a philosophical, Joseph Campbell-style exploration of our mythology than a simple Polack joke. My ice cream flavor entry: Hats Off to the Blueberry On BFF: Patty Haley, where are you? Ms. "Barf Folds Five" has remained curiously silent throughout this discussion. OK, here's something I've wanted to know for a long time now. Does anyone else break out with a serious case of the giggles with the blub-blub loo-loo-loo middle part of Brainiac's Daughter? ( I hope you know what I mean. I don't know how else to describe it, esp. since I don't have it here with me to listen too now ) That just cracks me up. I think it must take me back to when I was about 3 years old and Paul McCartney's Uncle Albert was a current hit. That song used to send me into 3-year-old convulsions. Anyone else have a song like that that just plain makes them laugh without knowing why? One last thing: I know there's lots of Ohioans out there. Lots of Northeast Ohioans at that. Anyone feel like hosting a get-together? If not, lets at least all meet at a restaurant like the Tokyo contingent and annoy the rest of the patrons with our singing. E me. Columbus would be nice and central, but I live in Kent if the nor'easters want to do something. I wouldn't know myself, but I imagine Kent might have a bar or two somewhere in the vicinity. (insert mondo smiley) And with that, I shall bid you all a fondue, er, I mean a fond adieu. What the hell, go out and have some fondue, everybody! --Melissa
------------------------------ Message-ID: <336F8395.E1C@sprintmail.com> Date: Tue, 06 May 1997 12:16:37 -0700 From: Stormy Monday <stormymonday@sprintmail.com> Subject: Ye Olde XTC Ice Cream Parlor Folxtc, Chunkiest Monkey Candy Andy Pie On The Wall Chocolate Chip Fireball Jingoistic Cake Sgt. Rocky Road Fig Day Sacrificial Bon Bons Merely Pecan Madame Barnum's Frosty Circus Cashew Tiger Stormy Monday
------------------------------ Subject: XTC Ice Cream Flavor From: wwilson@mail07.mitre.org (Wesley H. Wilson) Message-Id: <970506135445.12963@mail07.mitre.org.0> Date: Tue, 6 May 97 13:54:47 -0400 I have one more "XTC Ice Cream Flavor" to add to the list: Chunky Smartest Monkey
------------------------------ From: monnickj@ubk.co.uk Message-Id: <199705061806.TAA16190@sys4.cambridge.uk.psi.net> Date: Mon, 5 May 1997 17:58:15 +0000 Subject: harmonies HARMONIES - any recommendations for bands with great harmony singers ? This is, I hope, my final beatles related topic. Listening to Anthology 3 i realised that whatever was happening outside Jon & paul continued to sing together right to the end, continuing the tradition of don & phil. Thereafter that style of singing became redundant until. . . . any ideas? at least outside the dukes, the roches (see already covered) and bluegrass (such as Jim & Jesse). the Roches ; I'd agree with the sentiment expressed ; the can we go home now is a gem ; great singing and all sorts of lyrics the kinks ; strong support for the guys ; what are their great (non-compilation) albums ? Thanks for all who offered names for twins ; they are arrived at dawn of 30/3 and we named them Alexander Guy and Madeleine Eve. We are enjoying them immensely but still recovering. Any suggestions for music which would help them settle? Does anybody find their copy of the chalkhill digest arrive with the last 10 -20 % missing due to lack of space ? Anybody outside the UK read Nick Hornby's 'high fidelity' ? bye for now jon monnick *---------------------------------------------------------------- The views expressed are of the individual, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The United Bank of Kuwait PLC. *----------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------ Message-Id: <199705061833.UAA05456@utrecht.knoware.nl> From: "Mark Strijbos" <mmello@knoware.nl> Organization: The Little Lighthouse Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 19:39:17 +0000 Subject: I Scream Man Chalkers, First a big "thank you" to Tom for the nice XTC badges. Now on to some serious business: > So let's say someone like Ben and Jerry's was going to name an ice cream > flavor after XTC. What would they call it? How about Melt The Yums or Iceman/Snowman ? yours frostily, Mark Strijbos at The Little Lighthouse http://utopia.knoware.nl/~mmello ===> Mark's Random XTC Quote <=== Hail mother motor, hail piston rotor, hail wheel!
------------------------------ From: Richard.PedrettiAllen@octel.com Message-Id: <c=US%a=_%p=Octel%l=EX-CAMPUS1-970506195216Z-6643@ex-campus2.corp.octel.com> Subject: Tape Orders Received Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 12:52:16 -0700 I have received orders from the following people: A-G Jose Artecona, Todd Bernhardt, Ben Brand, Jason Brown, Steve Cameron, John Christenson*, Randy Christopher*, Phil Corless, Andy Cuthbert, Eric Day*, Pune Dracker, Bob Estus, Mark Fisher, Peter Fitzpatrick*, Mitch Friedman*, David Gershman, Greg Gillette, Ben Gott* H-P Scott Haefner, John Hedges*, Naoyuki Isogai*, Tim Kendrick*, Simon Knight, Jeffrey Langr, Richard Leighton, Ira Lieman, Andrew Lippitt, Ian Murphy, Robin Myrick*, Steve Perley*, Troy Peters, Randy Posynick* R-Z Dave Ray, Melissa Reaves*, John Relph, Della & Steve Schiavo, Tim Schreyer, Harrison Sherwood*, Charles Silverman, Thomas Slack*, J.D. Smelser, Jeff Smith, Ekram Soylemez, Chris Spillios*, Michael Stander, John Wilkens, Wesley Wilson, William Wisner, Jim Zittel * Contributor Orders total 96. Plenty left! Order soon to lower my blood pressure. Cheers, Richard Richard Pedretti-Allen Manager, GBS Phrase Development Octel Communications Corp. 1001 Murphy Ranch Rd. MS C1-2N Milpitas, CA 95035-7912 phone 408.324.4516 fax 408.324.6170
------------------------------ From: gopack@postoffice.worldnet.att.net Subject: Re: Dave Marsh Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 20:47:47 +0000 Message-ID: <19970506204744.AAA17560@CTX> I found Dave Marsh's analysis from "The New Rolling Stone Record Guide" (thanks Martin Monkman for reminding me that I actually owned that dinosaur!) simultaneously anachronistic and relevant. In 1983, XTC may have sweat "enough to earn its pretensions," but certainly not anymore. While I would still consider the band "avant-garde," they have grown far beyond a post-punk band that can "really rock out." Don't get me wrong - XTC is a great rock'n'roll band, but as all their fans will attest, they transcend ideas of traditional rock music. And as for XTC's nihilism - I don't think they were ever a truly rejectionist band - they never professed the destructiveness of the Sex Pistols, the activism of the Clash, the political acumen of the Gang of Four, or the complete goofiness of the Damned. I would like to term a new "ism" to describe the band: "XTCism." Anyway, my point: A friend and I have been engaged in a (at times) heated debate about Colin's songwriting ability. I have always appreciated Colin's "penchant for skewed art," while my friend strongly believes that his songs contribute nothing to the albums. One thing we do agree on: Colin's songs seem more "hit and miss" than Andy's. Therefore, on albums where Colin is given more opportunity to express his creativity (read: has more than three songs - such as "GO2"), he is more likely to have better material. Love to write more, but a t-storm is approaching. Peace. Matt "If you think there's a solution, you're automatically part of the problem." - George Carlin
------------------------------ Message-ID: <336FA03F.656B@virgin.net> Date: Tue, 06 May 1997 22:18:56 +0100 From: peter.wright2@virgin.net (peter.wright2@virgin.net) Subject: XTC - I love 'em ! Is it mutual ?? Hi all, I must say that I am very pleasantly surprised at the support I received after my last post (#107). I had fully expected to take such a severe beating that I wouldn't get up for some time. However, so far there has only been virtual agreement with my views . Sorry to have misjudged you! Special thanks to Kraig Olmstead for his email and sorry to Liz Neil whose post just wouldn't come through ! Most of you seem to agree with most of my thoughts but feel that some small label will pick up the band soon. Yes , I'm sure there are lots of small companies out there who would sign XTC but you see, I wonder if this is what XTC THEMSELVES want ? Remember, they have had the luxury of a huge label (Virgin) behind them for a very long time. Granted, Virgin were preoccupied with their other acts and left XTC on the shelf but the band knew that the Virgin cash was always there to bail them out. (Read the biography to see how many times THAT happened over the years.) With a small deal, the safety net is gone. And one thing still nags at me . If XTC simply want a new album out and just enough cash to cover their expenses and get them through til the next album ( as many of you seem to believe ), why the hell don't they put the album out on their OWN label ?? Nowadays recording costs are minimal, they could produce it themselves (less conflict !), design and press it themselves . The only deal they then need to broker is for promotion and distribution. Sounds simple enough to me. I think the reason is clear. What they really want is a big multi-national to take them on. And as I said in my last post, it seems unlikely. Again , I hope I'm wrong. A final querie. 'Chalkhills' has been going for a long time now. As many subscribers have told us, XTC are aware of it. Would it be such a hardship for at least one of the band to drop us a message sometime ? After all, they've had 5 years "on strike". Couldn't they spare us a few precious moments to say ....well, anything ! They know we are loyal fans who care about them and their music yet they totally ignore us and leave us completely in the dark about what - if anything - is going on. The chances are they probably don't even bother to look at 'Chalkhills' once in a while so they won't get this message. However, if anybody reading this knows any of the band, let them know that some of us out here are a little peeved at the bands lack of involvement with the people who have stuck by them through thick and (gossamer-like) thin. Come on, chaps. You know we'll continue to buy your brilliant music no matter what but if your at all interested in your fans , for God's sake get in touch !! If any flames are coming my way, now is the time ! But I think that I'm not alone on this one. Our allegiance is as strong as ever , but a little appreciation from time to time would be nice ! Pete.
------------------------------ Message-ID: <336FA43E.255C@prodigy.net> Date: Tue, 06 May 1997 21:35:58 +0000 From: dke <dke@prodigy.net> Organization: Prodigy Internet Subject: re: Rolling Stone blurbs... Hi there!, re: The Rolling Stone record guide, Dave Marsh is actually not the worst affront to XTC fans out there. I've got the 1992 edition of the guide. Mark Coleman (credited as 'the music reviewer for US magazine' gets to review XTC in this edition.) Picking up where Dave M. left off, he gives English Settlement only 3 stars, calling it and the next two albums, "cluttered and fussy affairs, with only the occasional hook rising from the intellectualized din." and "Partridge sounds woefully cynical (and nasal) on Mummers 'Funky Pop a Roll'(sic)" and "After 'Mummer', XTC retired from live performing." Aaagghh!! This guy is an idiot!...(take a few deep breaths Doug...o.k., I'm better now.) But anyway!, re: the long wait between albums, I'm also a Peter Gabriel fan (go ahead and hiss if you must) (Dave G. is on his 3rd album) and so I'm painfully used to waiting years (and years) between albums. (For those of you only familiar with his later MOR friendly material, listen to the 1st three albums. BTW, Robert Fripp is on all three.) Re: XTCers in Florida, are there any of you out there lurking in south Florida? Re: Talking Heads influenced bands, has anybody heard the new INXS single (I don't know the title) that I'm bombarded with at work five times a day? (radio in S. Fla, uhm...how you say...sucks) It sounds like they directly sampled 'Remain In Light's guitar parts and then decided to sing over them. And finally (everyone in unison: "Thank god!") re: the New Demo tapes, does anyone know where I can get a copy!!! Pleeeaasse!!!!!
------------------------------ Date: Tue, 6 May 1997 23:00:18 -0700 (PDT) From: Wesley Shaw <weshaw@teleport.com> Subject: Oranges and Lemons mini-disk for trade Message-ID: <Pine.GSO.3.96.970506225547.21513A-100000@linda.teleport.com> I recently stumbled across the aforementioned disks in a record store and decided that although I didn't need them, that there was probably some chalkhill type who did. i'm not looking for cash, but stuff (unless I can't get stuff). Message me personally if you're interested. They're actually pretty cool. -Weshaw weshaw@teleport.COM Public Access User -- Not affiliated with Teleport Public Access UNIX and Internet at (503) 220-1016 (2400-28800, N81)
------------------------------ Message-Id: <2.2.32.19970507155641.006acbe0@popmail.dircon.co.uk> Date: Wed, 07 May 1997 16:56:41 +0100 From: Simon Sleightholm <nonsuch@dircon.co.uk> Subject: Political Party Animal From: james.dignan@stonebow.otago.ac.nz (James Dignan) >but what of the following lyric from "Blue Overall" (which >would have been written deep in the heart of Thatcher's reign): >"I tried to lose myself in labour/The more I push the mirth/I'm giving >birth to a baby turning/blue overall..." Nifty notion, James, especially when you consider that blue is the colour of all things Conservative. Of course Andy gave Thatcher a few jabs in the face on "Reign Of Blows" from the same period - "Iron maidens will slam" (Iron Maiden was one of her many nicknames) and "Violence is only a vote for the Black Queen to take back the throne" (many believe the Conservative government would never have been re-elected after their first term if it hadn't been for the rally-round-the-flag jingoism instilled during the Falklands conflict). But as he says in the same song "By the half light of burning republics, Joe Stalin looks just like Uncle Sam"; in other words, no matter what colours you fly, when you trangress the basic human rights issues you are a villain - and it doesn't seem as if Andy has much truck with _any_ party within the current British system. Around the time of Oranges And Lemons Andy did an interview with Jonnie Walker in which he decried voting as something of a waste of time, reckoning all political parties to be much the same - they'll all take a few pence off this, but put a few pence on that and life continues much as normal. If, though, the government started dragging his family out of bed in the middle of the night, then he'd do something about it - not with a voting slip, but with a gun and some bombs. Voting was, he thought, a huge con, a sop to the public to make them think they actually have some control over the way their country is governed. His general opinion of politicians seems to be roughly in line with that of comedian Billy Connolly's - "The desire to be a politician should bar you for life from ever actually becoming one." Also, Sister Ray Records, 94 Berwick Street, Soho, London, W1V 3PP (phone: 0171 287 8385, fax: 0171 287 1087, email: sisterray@thenet.co.uk) are selling 'The Disappointed' 10" Single for 1.99 (Sterling) at the moment. Simon +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+ http://www.users.dircon.co.uk/~nonsuch/bungalow.htm +-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+ XTC? Are they still going? Follow me and find out..
------------------------------ End of Chalkhills Digest #3-109 *******************************
Go back to Volume 3.
8 May 1997 / Feedback